What is Vendor Scorecard?

A vendor scorecard is a tool used by organizations to evaluate and measure the performance of their suppliers or vendors against predefined criteria or key performance indicators (KPIs). These criteria typically include factors such as quality, delivery, cost, responsiveness, compliance, and overall relationship management.

For procurement professionals, their role isn’t over when the contract is signed. In fact, it has just begun. Building vendor relationships is a key skill, and managing vendor performance is crucial. The supplier scorecard provides a way to bring organization and objectivity to your vendor evaluation, enabling you to leverage the results to increase vendor value, improve performance, and optimize your procurement strategy.

After the request for proposal (RFP) process, final vendor selection, and contracting, the procurement team onboards the new vendor. Ideally, the onboarding agenda includes an overview of the vendor evaluation process, and that’s where vendor scorecards come into play.

Compare and contrast the current vendor’s results with his previous ones and the other vendors using this vendor scorecard tracker.

How Vendor Scorecard Works

Here's how a vendor scorecard typically works and how it aids in supplier onboarding: 

Establishing Criteria

Before onboarding a supplier, the organization defines the criteria that are important for evaluating supplier performance. These criteria should be aligned with the organization's goals and priorities. 

Measurement Metrics

Each criterion is broken down into specific metrics or KPIs. For example, quality might be measured by defect rates or customer complaints, while delivery performance could be assessed by on-time delivery rates. 

Scoring System

A scoring system is established to quantify performance against each metric. This could be a numerical scale (e.g., 1-5) or a percentage-based system. 

Use this ready-to-use worksheet to evaluate the overall performance of your vendors based on Carter's 10 Cs model. It helps either you are already engaged with vendors or are planning to work with them.

Data Collection

Data is collected from various sources such as internal records, supplier reports, customer feedback, and performance assessments. 

Evaluation

The collected data is then used to evaluate the supplier's performance against the predefined criteria and metrics. 

Scorecard Generation

A scorecard is generated for each supplier, summarizing their performance across different criteria and providing an overall performance score. 

Decision Making

Based on the scores obtained, organizations can make informed decisions about whether to onboard a supplier, continue existing relationships, or take corrective actions to address any performance issues. 

How Vendor Scorecard helps in Supplier Onboarding and Supplier Performance Management 

• Objective Evaluation: A vendor scorecard provides an objective way to evaluate potential suppliers during the onboarding process. This ensures that decisions are based on measurable criteria rather than subjective opinions. 
• Risk Mitigation: By systematically assessing suppliers against predefined criteria, organizations can identify potential risks early in the onboarding process and take appropriate measures to mitigate them. 
• Performance Improvement: By setting clear expectations and regularly measuring performance, vendor scorecards encourage suppliers to improve their performance over time, leading to better overall outcomes for the organization. 
• Transparency and Accountability: Vendor scorecards promote transparency and accountability in supplier relationships by providing clear feedback on performance and fostering open communication between the organization and its suppliers. 

Download this ready-to-use editable supplier KPI worksheet to start measuring your suppliers' performance, positively impacting your organization, and turning procurement into a value driver.

Closing Note 

Overall, a vendor scorecard is a valuable tool for ensuring that organizations onboard the right suppliers and manage their relationships effectively to drive better business outcomes. 

Explore Additional Resources to Know More